Game changer alert.
Every once in a while a really simply recipe does the rounds that gets even nay-sayers to love an ingredient they usually avoid.
Now, I love mushrooms and always have done – earthy and woody, rich, deep and meaty, they’re an ingredient I couldn’t be without. And whilst many folks feel the same, many dislike them too. If like me you love them but you know someone who doesn’t – I beg you to cook this for them and see if you can change their mind. It’s worked for me several times and helping convert someone to something feels rather satisfying/smug (delete as appropriate).
I picked up this recipe a few years ago (cough) when I moved out of home for the first time. I was 18 and sharing with a number of boys in a rather dodgy part of town (parties were our main focus, living a respectable lifestyle was not). Matt, one of the boys had worked in a couple of kitchens in town and one morning when I set about frying mushrooms in butter he gave me a tip.
“Poach them in milk” he said. I was skeptical, it didn’t sound like a match made in heaven but trusting him I went with it. He was right on the money and I’ve cooked them in milk ever since, be it for mushrooms at breakfast or mushrooms for a mid week dinner.
It’s a beautifully simple way to cook the little mushroom. You fry them in foaming butter until they’re browned and begin to ‘squeak’, then to add lots of black pepper and enough full fat milk to cover them, and turn the heat to its lowest and let them poach uncovered very gently for around 30 minutes, only salting them at the end of cooking. It may take a while but it’s low involvement so ideal when you’re busy.
The milk reduces down and creates a very creamy sauce around the mushrooms, keeping them rich and nutty tasting and very juicy – beautiful on toasted sourdough or even a crisp potato rosti. You can keep it really simple using regular white or chestnut mushrooms, or use a mixture of mushroom varieties for even greater flavour like I have here. And they’re tasty just on their own or finished with other flavours - parsley, tarragon, English mustard or garlic are all great additions.
For two as a meal
- 300g white mushrooms – cut around half in half and leave the others whole – and do not wash them
- 250g chestnut mushrooms – same as above for cutting and washing
- 150g shiitake mushrooms – same as above for cutting and washing
- 40g unsalted butter
- Enough full fat milk to cover them in the saucepan (you can use half fat but it often splits – it doesn’t change the flavour but it doesn’t look great)
- A handful fresh tarragon, finely chopped just before it’s needed
- 2 teaspoons English mustard
- Sea salt
- Black pepper
- Sourdough bread for toasting – as much as you fancy eating
- In a deep saucepan heat the butter on a high heat until it foams, then add the mushrooms, stir them every minute or so until they become nutty and brown on each side, this will take around 5 to 7 minutes. Add enough milk to just cover them and a lot of black pepper, then turn the heat on low and leave them uncovered to poach. Stir them every 5 to 10 minutes to make sure they don’t catch.
- You’re looking for the milk to reduce right down around them and create a sauce thats not quite as thick as single cream. When you get to this stage take them off the heat, and if you accidentally go beyond this stage just add some more milk to the pan.
- Stir in the chopped tarragon and mustard and give a scrunch of sea salt – taste the seasoning to make sure you’re happy, then serve them on top of toasted sour dough.